$22 Billion in Bank Perpetual Preferred Shares Stuck Deep in Losses, Holders Left with No Way Out
nashnova research
Roughly $22 billion in fixed-for-life preferred stock issued by U.S. banks during the pandemic has fallen nearly 40% since issuance, trading at about 61 cents on the dollar; every issuer that has reached a call window has walked away, leaving holders trapped.
What are these securities, and why have they crashed?
Fixed-for-life perpetual preferred stock — securities whose coupon never resets and that the bank never has to repay — was issued heavily in 2020–2021, when rates sat near zero. Coupons were typically below 5%.
This means → banks locked in ultra-cheap capital, but buyers locked in an ultra-low fixed return. Once rates rose, that return fell far behind the market.
This year alone the total return on the class is down 8.5%. Since issuance the cumulative decline is nearly 40%, with the average price around 61 cents on the dollar.
Why won't the banks call them back?
Calling the stock means replacing it with new debt at today's higher rates. In plain terms = old coupons run below 5%; new issuance of the same product now averages 6.69%. Swapping would cost more — so banks simply don't.
JPMorgan and Wells Fargo have already skipped their call windows. A $1.3 billion Morgan Stanley preferred reaches its call date in January; it trades at about 61.4 cents, with the market pricing in virtually no chance of redemption. Morgan Stanley declined to comment.
Regulators bar banks from adding any call-incentive provisions to preferred-stock terms. This means → the decision is purely economic, and the economics clearly say "don't call."
Could the rate picture get even worse?
The U.S. 10-year Treasury yield this week pushed back toward 5%, driven by inflation data showing persistent price pressure and rising expectations of further Fed rate hikes.
This reflects a near-zero probability that rates move in holders' favor any time soon — the higher yields go, the further these low-coupon securities fall.
The lowest-coupon issue, a 3.75% series from U.S. Bancorp, now trades at roughly 55 cents on the dollar.
What options do holders have left?
UBS strategist Frank Sileo compares these securities to century bonds: "Would you buy a 100-year bond? No? That's what you bought."
Put simply = holders face two paths: hold on, absorbing paper losses while collecting a coupon far below market rates; or sell at a deep discount, exiting at sixty cents or less on the dollar.
Bloomberg Intelligence analyst Arnold Kakuda notes that perpetual securities could, in theory, rebound and eventually be called — but concedes that the odds of a rate move in holders' favor are very low in the near term.
The seeds of dramatic losses were sown back in 2020 and 2021.
Frank Sileo
Senior Fixed-Income Strategist, UBS Chief Investment Office Americas
(commenting on the fixed-for-life preferred stock market)
市场有风险,内容仅供研究参考,不构成投资建议。
