BofA Research: DRAM Price Hikes Continue, NAND Spot Prices Pull Back 20% with Growing Divergence
nashnova research
BofA's Nov 13 report flags a clear divergence in memory chips — DRAM pricing logic remains intact, but NAND spot has pulled back ~20% since mid-October, potentially becoming the first segment that needs repricing in this upcycle.
How far has NAND spot fallen, and how does DRAM compare?
Per DRAMeXchange, 512Gb NAND wafer spot sits at $14.30, down 32% quarter-on-quarter and ~20% since mid-October; the 1Tb wafer is at $24.90, down 19% QoQ.
By contrast, 16Gb DDR5 spot holds at $60.20, flat week-on-week. This means → DRAM hasn't budged while NAND spot is visibly softening — the two are diverging.
In plain terms = both are memory chips, but DRAM is still in an upcycle while NAND is cooling off — the "everything rallies together" story no longer holds.
Why might NAND's pricing power be shifting?
BofA points to three warning signs: spot prices down ~20%; weakening orders from PC and smartphone OEMs and Chinese hyperscale cloud buyers; and Q1 2027 contract negotiations that may be delayed, with no rush-order activity in sight.
Contract and spot prices are diverging. The 512Gb contract price still hovers near its all-time high of ~$27 — roughly ten times the Feb 2025 trough of $2.50 — yet spot has already broken lower.
This reflects a timing problem: if downstream buyers keep holding off, Q1 2027 contract talks get pushed back and vendors lose bargaining leverage.
How far is BofA's NAND call from the Street?
Sell-side consensus assumes NAND ASPs will still rise >10%. BofA sees IT NAND prices falling 5–10% QoQ and overall NAND declining low-single-digits — a gap of over 15 percentage points.
Structural pressure adds to the concern: legacy fabs account for 20–30% of global wafer capacity, unsuitable for high-end NAND or enterprise SSDs, yet still needed for IT NAND — consumer-grade memory for PCs and smartphones — creating a price overhang.
Vendors argue strong enterprise-SSD demand can offset IT NAND weakness, but BofA sees that offset as limited.
What keeps DRAM prices rising?
Per TrendForce, 16Gb DDR5 contract prices rose 5% MoM in October, up over 500% year-on-year; server 64GB module contracts climbed ~15% MoM, breaking through $1,000 to reach $1,600 (DDR5) and $1,500 (DDR4).
BofA maintains its DRAM price-hike assumptions: +8% QoQ in Q4 2026, +5% in Q1 2027. This means → two forces keep the market tight — robust AI data-center demand and HBM — high-bandwidth memory, a specialized high-speed DRAM designed for AI chips — crowding out conventional DRAM capacity.
At a Nov 12 investor session with Samsung, BofA heard three takeaways: strong US AI chip demand with no order cuts; markedly improved HBM positioning; and DRAM contract prices trending firmly up and sustainable over a longer cycle.
How aggressive is Samsung on HBM?
Samsung targets an HBM share of 30–40%, not the 50%+ some expected — management is deliberately leaving room.
The reason: even through end-2027, LPDDR5 profitability still exceeds HBM's. This means → Samsung won't sacrifice its more profitable conventional DRAM line just to chase HBM share — capacity expansion will stay measured.
In plain terms = HBM grabs headlines, but legacy memory earns more — Samsung is playing both sides rather than going all-in on HBM.
Are memory stocks cheap, and what's the key test?
Memory stocks rebounded this week; year-to-date gains top 100% across the board, with SanDisk and Kioxia returning over 250%. Yet multiples remain subdued: SK Hynix trades at 3.6× 2026E P/E, Samsung at 4.7×, Micron at 10.7×.
BofA argues memory valuations look modest versus AI-semiconductor peers, and DRAM-heavy names are seen as having limited downside.
The valuation gap and earnings elasticity between DRAM and NAND names ultimately hinge on whether Q1 2027 contract negotiations land on schedule — the decisive test of whether NAND pricing power has truly shifted.
市场有风险,内容仅供研究参考,不构成投资建议。
