CATL Founder Challenges Europe's Battery Recycling Localization Policy

nashnova research
今天发布阅读约 10 分钟

CATL Chairman Robin Zeng proposed shipping Europe's spent batteries to China for recycling, calling local recycling infrastructure permanently uncompetitive on cost — a direct challenge to the EU's push for battery supply-chain self-sufficiency.

01

What exactly is Zeng proposing?

The core idea: ship Europe's end-of-life batteries to China for the full shredding → black mass extraction → metal refining chain, then return the refined metals to Europe.
Speaking at the APEC CEO Summit in Shenzhen, Zeng asked bluntly: why build a local facility with zero cost competitiveness from shredding to refining? The bill, he said, lands on consumers.
This means → CATL is positioning itself as Europe's outsourced recycling service provider, not just a battery supplier.
02

Why can't Europe simply agree?

The EU has classified spent lithium-ion batteries and black mass — the mixed powder left after dismantling batteries, containing lithium, cobalt, nickel and other critical metals — as hazardous materials, effectively barring exports to non-OECD countries.
In plain terms = Europe's rule is: the metals inside old batteries are strategic resources, and they must not leave.
China controls roughly 85% of global lithium-ion battery capacity and an even larger share of recycling capability; Europe's local recycling capacity remains constrained by high costs and permitting delays.
This reflects a structural deadlock: Europe lacks sufficient recycling capacity yet has regulatory barriers blocking the most efficient external solution.
03

What is wrong with the concept of "localization" itself?

Zeng questioned the feasibility of "100% localization": assembling batteries in Europe counts, producing cathode and anode materials locally counts — but where do the minerals come from?
Europe lacks critical mineral deposits. Lithium, cobalt and similar raw materials must ultimately be imported from Africa or other resource-rich regions.
This means → "localization" in the battery value chain can only cover the mid- and downstream. The upstream resource link will always depend on external supply — 100% localization is a logically unsustainable slogan.
04

How is CATL's European expansion going?

Its German plant is operational; a Spanish plant with Stellantis is under construction; but the Hungarian plant is already months behind schedule.
Peer companies in Europe also face probes into environmental compliance, fire safety and labor standards — This means → the pushback is not aimed at CATL alone but represents systematic scrutiny of all Chinese battery makers in Europe.
The EU has imposed additional tariffs on Chinese EVs and plans to restrict hybrid-vehicle imports. The battery supply chain has become one of the core battlegrounds in China-EU trade friction.
05

What signal does CATL's cooperative stance send?

Zeng said CATL remains open to partnerships and technology licensing, citing its deal with Ford Motor in the U.S. as a model that helped Ford produce batteries locally and has broadly met expectations.
He argued overseas cooperation should be measured by "local contribution," not by the investor's nationality.
In plain terms = CATL's position is: we can teach you to fish, or we can hand you the fish — but you have to be willing to accept cooperation, not demand technology while erecting barriers.
This reflects CATL keeping two paths open simultaneously: direct investment in local plants, or pure technology licensing for royalty income — whichever route proves viable.

市场有风险,内容仅供研究参考,不构成投资建议。