OpenAI Fights Back Against Apple Trade Secret Lawsuit: Allegations Baseless, Aimed at Blocking Recruitment
nashnova research
OpenAI filed a late-Monday legal response dismantling Apple's trade-secret theft claims point by point, arguing the real goal is to stop talent from leaving — a dispute that signals direct hardware competition between the two companies.
What exactly is Apple alleging?
Apple sued in the Northern District of California, claiming former employees Tang Tan and Chang Liu took confidential information when they left. Both now work at OpenAI.
Tang Tan spent roughly twenty-four years at Apple, rising to senior director on the product design team, working closely with former chief design officer Jony Ive.
This means → Apple is not targeting rank-and-file engineers. It is targeting veterans who sat at the core of Apple's design process — the lawsuit's real weight is about people, not files.
How does OpenAI rebut each claim?
On Tang Tan: OpenAI says the files he emailed himself before leaving were non-confidential documents, personal notes, and a widely circulated management checklist — no trade secrets.
On the accusation that Tan encouraged interviewees to bring Apple "physical parts": OpenAI responds the parts were older or commercially available components used as demo aids — standard practice in engineering interviews.
On Chang Liu: OpenAI says Apple employees contacted Liu after he left, asking for help locating files. He simply complied with their requests.
Why does OpenAI call this "a mess of Apple's own making"?
OpenAI points to flaws in Apple's offboarding process: Apple encouraged employees to use personal accounts for work, then blamed them for taking those accounts when they left.
In plain terms = Apple blurred the line between "company" and "personal," and is now suing over the gray zone it created.
This reflects a broader pattern: large tech companies' internal offboarding gaps tend to surface only when the talent war intensifies.
What is the real battlefield behind this lawsuit?
OpenAI's filing cites roughly 400 employees who have left Apple for OpenAI, stating: "Apple cannot stop the next 400 from leaving by filing baseless lawsuits."
In 2024 the two companies partnered to integrate ChatGPT into Siri. Apple's new Siri AI, launched this June, is now powered by Google Gemini — the partnership is over.
OpenAI also disclosed that its first expected hardware product is "a novel consumer device materially different from Apple's existing products" — pointing to direct competition in AI hardware.
This means → The lawsuit is not just an offboarding dispute. It is a signal that, after the partnership collapsed, Apple is using legal action to slow a rival's hardware push.
市场有风险，内容仅供研究参考，不构成投资建议。