U.S. Federal Judge Refuses to Dismiss DRAM Antitrust Lawsuit; Samsung, SK Hynix, and Micron Enter Discovery Phase
nashnova research
A U.S. federal judge denied Samsung, SK Hynix, and Micron's motion to dismiss a DRAM price-fixing class action — the three must respond by Dec 7 and begin turning over internal documents, making this lawsuit a key variable for global memory-chip supply expectations.
What is this lawsuit actually about?
In June 2025, 17 plaintiffs from five U.S. states sued Samsung, SK Hynix, and Micron, alleging the three conspired to restrict conventional DRAM supply.
The plaintiffs — 14 consumers and 3 small PC assemblers — seek class-action status, injunctive relief, and treble damages.
This means → if collusion is ultimately proven, the companies face not an ordinary fine but damages multiplied by three under U.S. antitrust law.
Why wasn't it thrown out this time? Didn't a nearly identical case fail before?
In 2020, a near-identical suit was dismissed. The Ninth Circuit upheld that ruling, calling simultaneous output cuts normal oligopoly behavior.
The defendants recycled that playbook: the new complaint is just the old conspiracy theory with an AI narrative overlay.
Judge Noël Wise found material differences. She offered a pointed analogy: defendants cited Judge Posner's argument that rivals in concentrated markets naturally watch each other. Wise responded that what the plaintiffs described "looks more like eagles flying in formation" — and formation flying is not natural eagle behavior.
In plain terms = the judge is saying the three companies moved in lockstep to a degree that exceeds any plausible "each independently read market signals and happened to do the same thing" explanation.
What "abnormal" evidence did the plaintiffs present?
A prior cartel: in the 1998–2002 DRAM price-fixing case, Samsung paid $300 million in fines, SK Hynix paid $185 million, and Micron received immunity for cooperating.
Synchronized cuts: from late 2022 to April 2023, SK Hynix and Micron announced production cuts; Samsung followed roughly two months later. All three then pivoted capacity to HBM (high-bandwidth memory — a premium chip memory built for AI processors) and locked in long-term supply contracts.
Synchronized DDR4 phase-out: in Q2 2025, all three announced mainstream DDR4 end-of-life in the same quarter; in December 2025, Micron shut down its consumer brand Crucial; in January 2026, all three adopted nearly identical customer-qualification questionnaires.
This means → the plaintiffs' core argument is that no single company would sacrifice profits by cutting output alone unless it had assurance the others would follow — that assurance, they allege, is collusion.
How much did conventional DRAM prices rise?
Plaintiffs' data shows conventional DRAM prices rose 697% within 18 months during the output-restriction period.
No meaningful new capacity came online; new fab construction was delayed or shelved.
Plaintiffs argue Samsung, as market leader, broke years of precedent by following smaller rivals into cuts — a "profit sacrifice" potentially costing tens to hundreds of billions of dollars.
In plain terms = the three shifted ordinary-memory capacity to AI-grade premium memory, and ordinary-memory prices exploded. The plaintiffs say that was not coincidence — it was coordination.
What happens next — and why should the market care?
Surviving a motion to dismiss is only a procedural first step — it is far from a final finding of collusion.
But once discovery begins — the legal process forcing both sides to hand over internal documents — the three companies' internal communications and decision records face scrutiny.
This means → even if no conviction follows, documents surfaced during discovery could reshape market expectations for memory-chip supply on their own. The trajectory of this lawsuit is now one of the core variables for the global memory market.
市场有风险,内容仅供研究参考,不构成投资建议。
