Visa and Mastercard Seek $38 Billion Settlement to End 21-Year Merchant Dispute
nashnova research
Visa and Mastercard are asking a federal judge to approve a $38 billion settlement that would end a 21-year antitrust lawsuit over credit-card swipe fees, covering more than 12 million merchants — but over a thousand objectors, including Walmart, stand in the way.
What has this 21-year lawsuit been about?
The core dispute is the interchange fee — the cut merchants pay banks and card networks on every credit-card transaction. Merchants argue Visa and Mastercard set it jointly, amounting to a monopoly.
The case covers more than 12 million U.S. merchants, making it one of the largest antitrust actions in the American payments industry.
This means → It is not a spat between two companies and a few big retailers. It is a collective challenge by essentially the entire U.S. retail sector against the card networks' pricing power.
What would merchants actually get under this deal?
Standard consumer credit-card interchange fees would drop by 0.1 percentage point over five years, then be capped at 1.25% for eight more years.
Retailers would be allowed to reject premium credit cards at specific stores while still accepting regular cards on the same network.
In plain terms = Visa and Mastercard have long enforced an "honor-all-cards" rule — accept our network, accept every card on it, including the ones with the highest fees. This settlement loosens that rule for the first time, letting merchants pick which cards to take.
Why are over a thousand parties objecting?
Walmart, Circle K, and the National Retail Federation, among more than a thousand objectors, argue the fee reduction is too small and the cap period too short.
Visa's own lawyer conceded in court that Visa is not "thrilled" about the changes — but called the deal "robust" relief that would "change how the networks operate."
This reflects a settlement that neither side loves — which is precisely what a forced compromise looks like, rather than a victory for either party.
Will the judge approve it — and what happens next?
Federal Judge Brian Cogan held a hearing Monday in Brooklyn, New York, but did not rule from the bench.
Cogan signaled that rejecting the deal would send the case to a full trial, potentially extending the litigation by years.
This means → This proposal is itself a revision — an earlier $30 billion settlement was rejected by the court in June 2024. The judge now faces a choice: approve an imperfect deal, or let a lawsuit that has already run 21 years keep running.
市场有风险,内容仅供研究参考,不构成投资建议。
