1. 首页
  2. ›War Premium Drops to Zero: Goldman Sachs Sees Entry Window to Buy Commodity Hedges

War Premium Drops to Zero: Goldman Sachs Sees Entry Window to Buy Commodity Hedges

N
nashnova research
·今天发布·阅读约 19 分钟

Brent's geopolitical risk premium has collapsed from $27 per barrel to just a few dollars. Goldman's 2027 outlook argues the drawdown makes commodities far cheaper as portfolio insurance — and insurance is most worth buying when it is cheapest.

01

Why did the premium vanish so fast?

•
Goldman's commodity head Daan Struyven attributes the November sell-off in energy and copper to a sentiment reset and fading Middle East escalation expectations, not to deteriorating physical supply-demand.
•
Brent posted its largest weekly decline since 2020 in the week after the midterm elections, as Qatar mediation headlines landed.
•
This means → the price drop reflects "fear unwinding," not "fundamentals collapsing" — Goldman treats it as an entry window, not an exit signal.
02

Is the physical market actually fine?

•
Crude level: Persian Gulf exports — including "dark barrels" Goldman has tracked since September — recovered to near-2025 levels by September, but Goldman expects the global crude market may have returned to surplus by October.
•
Refined products and LNG tell a different story — they cannot be rerouted via ship-to-ship transfers the way crude can. Damaged refineries, aluminium smelters, and liquefaction units remain only partially repaired, and Gulf exports of products, LNG, aluminium feedstock, and fertiliser stay well below pre-war levels.
•
On freight, Goldman estimates rerouting accounts for roughly three-quarters of the ~$20/barrel year-on-year rise in global average crude shipping costs — most of which passes through to end-user prices.
•
In plain terms = crude itself is "roughly adequate," but downstream processing remains the weak link — the closer to the consumer, the more fragile the supply.
03

What is Goldman's case for buying hedges now?

•
Case 1: Energy carries upside tail risk. Tanker attacks near the Strait of Hormuz have risen recently; Goldman expects this risk to increase further. If tensions re-escalate to a 3.5 million barrel/day Gulf supply gap, Brent could average $130/barrel in 2027.
•
Case 2: Equities and bonds are now tightly correlated with oil. Since the Iran war began, Brent's 6-month rolling correlation with the 10-year Treasury yield has climbed to ~0.5, while its correlation with the S&P 500 has dropped to ~-0.45. This means → a supply shock replay could send stocks and bonds down together. Goldman notes that across all twelve-month periods in the past sixty years when both stocks and bonds posted negative real returns, gold or commodities delivered positive real returns.
•
Case 3: Agriculture faces multiple upside pressures. Hormuz-linked fertiliser trade (~one-third of global fertiliser exports), Black Sea grain (15%–20% of global grain trade), biofuel substitution, and a record-strength El Niño all push prices higher.
04

What trades does Goldman recommend — and why skip crude?

•
Goldman does not go outright long crude. Instead it recommends two asymmetric trades:
•
Long RBOB gasoline (H1 2027) — refining capacity damage plus elevated freight passing through to downstream makes gasoline supply more fragile than crude itself.
•
Long European natural gas front-month (TTF Winter 2027) — European inventories are low; a cold snap combined with LNG disruption could drive a sharp price spike. Goldman's 2027 TTF average forecast is €45/MWh, but the Q1 extreme scenario reaches €147; Goldman assigns a 30% probability to the winter low-supply scenario.
•
In plain terms = crude already has plenty of sellers and limited upside; but downstream gasoline and natural gas are "insurance that nobody has bought yet" — the odds are better.
05

What about metals and gold?

•
Copper: bullish. Goldman targets LME copper at $15,600/tonne by December 2027, ~13% above spot. Drivers include US tariff uncertainty pulling metal into American warehouses, and tighter Chinese scrap-copper invoicing rules forcing processors toward refined cathode copper.
•
Aluminium: bearish. Ample bauxite supply plus China-backed Indonesian smelting expansion (projected to reach ~4% of global output by end-2027, up from ~1% at end-2025) will push the market into surplus. Target: $2,600/tonne. Goldman recommends a long December copper / short December aluminium pairs trade, noting it has lower sensitivity to an AI-cycle reversal or further Fed hikes than an outright long.
•
Gold: target trimmed to $4,650/oz. Goldman's economists now expect the Fed to hike another 25 bp in March 2027 on top of the December hike. Even so, $4,650 is ~16% above spot, with central-bank buying — sustained above pre-2022 levels — seen as the floor.
Premium at zero — golden entry for hedges, or a warning from the physical market?
BULL
Insurance is cheapest now
Premium collapse slashes hedge cost; tail risk has not disappeared.
The only positive return when stocks and bonds both fall
Sixty-year data: in every period of joint negative real returns, gold or commodities were positive.
Downstream is more fragile than upstream
Gasoline and LNG recovery lags crude — asymmetric opportunity persists.
BEAR
Physical market is already soft
Morgan Stanley notes Dated Brent has dropped below the front-month futures contract.
Surplus is the real issue
JPMorgan estimates a ~1.4 million b/d global crude surplus in October.
Premium fade may be the new normal
If geopolitical risk keeps cooling, the hedge may never pay off.
In plain terms = Goldman and its critics largely agree on the fundamentals — the debate is whether you should pay for insurance against a low-probability extreme shock, or follow the direction the physical market is already pointing. The answer depends on what happens at the Strait of Hormuz.
06

Will this "insurance" ever pay off?

•
Goldman's own base case is modest: Brent averages $88, and the Bloomberg Commodity Index return is near zero — surplus is baked into the forecast.
•
This means → Goldman is not saying "commodities will rally." It is saying "with the base case flat, you can buy tail-risk insurance cheaply."
•
This reflects a portfolio-construction mindset: the value of a hedge is not about the base case — it is about being the only component still working when everything else fails in an extreme scenario.

市场有风险,内容仅供研究参考,不构成投资建议。

相关标的

2
  • F&F383220.KR-0.3%

    Core event-driven asset. With the geopolitical premium reset to zero, Goldman Sachs believes tail risks remain, increasing upside asymmetry.

  • SPDR Gold SharesGLD.ETF+0.2%

    Goldman's $4,650 target implies ~16% upside. Central bank gold purchases provide support, offering a hedge against tail risks of simultaneous equity and bond selloffs.