U.S. Protests to Germany Over Yen Intervention Criticism and Russia Stance
nashnova research
During the G20 finance ministers' meeting, the U.S. formally protested Germany's public criticism of uncoordinated yen intervention and its refusal to appear alongside Russia — an open transatlantic clash that clouds the outlook for multilateral policy coordination.
Why is Germany unhappy about the yen intervention?
The U.S. sold euros to prop up the yen without consulting European partners first.
Bundesbank president Joachim Nagel said publicly that Washington should have coordinated before touching the euro.
This means → the U.S. unilaterally used a currency Europeans share exposure to, and Germany sees that as bypassing an ally's right to be informed.
The U.S. Treasury formally protested Nagel's remarks.
Why did the Russian finance minister's attendance trigger a photo-op crisis?
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent invited Russian Finance Minister Anton Siluanov without notifying other G20 members.
German Finance Minister Lars Klingbeil refused to appear with Siluanov in the traditional group photo; other European delegates backed him. Siluanov was excluded from the photo at the last minute.
In plain terms = the U.S. wanted Russia back at the table; Europe refused — they would not even stand in the same frame.
"Turned his back" — whose version is right?
Bessent publicly accused Klingbeil of standing up and turning his back while the Russian minister spoke.
But sources dispute this: Klingbeil spoke directly to Siluanov and urged him to end the war on Ukraine.
This means → the same moment, two opposite narratives — who was avoiding whom is a matter of whose account you trust.
Where else did Germany push back publicly?
Before leaving for the U.S., Klingbeil had already signaled criticism; during the summit he repeatedly called the Iran war and trade conflicts "poison for the economy."
He also sharply protested the U.S. Treasury's restrictions on press access to the G20, calling it "unacceptable" to deny credentials to individual reporters or entire news organizations.
Bloomberg and The Wall Street Journal reporters were denied credentials by the U.S. Treasury.
Germany's finance ministry lobbied at the highest diplomatic level and succeeded in one of two cases.
What does this friction tell us?
This reflects a pattern: since Trump's return to the White House, the U.S. and Europe have clashed repeatedly over trade tariffs and the Russia-Ukraine war.
The G20 confrontation was no behind-closed-doors disagreement — it played out in front of every member state.
In plain terms = the baseline trust underpinning multilateral coordination is eroding, and markets should brace for more frequent friction between allies.
市场有风险，内容仅供研究参考，不构成投资建议。